With the majority of S&P 500 (SPX) companies having released their 2026 Q3 earnings report, today, we wanted to review how stocks behaved based on their technical rating.
With the majority of S&P 500 (SPX) companies having released their 2026 Q3 earnings report, today, we wanted to review how stocks behaved based on their technical rating. For instance, did stocks with a high technical attribute (TA) rating beat fundamental analyst estimates more frequently than low TA stocks? Did high TA stocks behave better on their earnings date compared to low TA stocks? Were there more technical upgrades in certain sectors compared to others?
Before answering these questions, we should first give a brief overview of our ratings for those unfamiliar. Note that we will often use the terms technical attribute, attribute, and rating interchangeably. If you are a veteran, go ahead and skip to the “High Attributes vs Low Attributes on Estimates” section.
For those still reading, every stock on our system is assigned a rating that ranges from 0 to 5. Stocks with an attribute of 2 or below are considered technically weak, and consequently, carry a sell rating. Stocks with a 3 rating are considered a hold, and those with a 4 or 5 attribute are given buy and strong buy ratings, respectively. Our studies show that high rated stocks, which carry a 3 technical attribute or better, have historically outperformed stocks with low technical attribute ratings. Academics attribute this success to the momentum factor. It is a weird phenomenon, but it is as simple as stocks that have gone up the most in the past tend to keep going the most in the future.
By no means did we discover momentum — we merely provide an objective and quantifiable means to access the factor via our technical attributes. These ratings were not built with the intention of chasing near-term alpha nor should they be heavily relied upon for short-term trading; however, closely rated stocks tend to behave similarly in certain seasons — one of them being earnings season.
High Attributes vs Low Attributes on Estimates
More stocks rated as a hold, buy, or strong buy (high technical attribute, 3+) heading into this earnings season beat fundamental analyst expectations compared to stocks rated as a sell (weak technical attribute, 2 or lower). In fact, 80% of high technical attribute stocks beat top line, mean fundamental analyst estimates sourced by FactSet, a 3% decrease compared to Q2 2026. Meanwhile, 88% of high technical attribute stocks beat bottom line estimates, matching Q2 2026. The percentage of low attribute stocks that beat top line estimates fell again this quarter, down to 67%, while beats on bottom line estimates for low attribute names fell 2% from Q2 to 82% in Q3. The overall percentages/trends for Q3 2026 saw a slight decrease in top & bottom-line beats among high and low attribute stocks. Companies have numerous opportunities to manage their earnings per share via revenue recognition practices, depreciation/amortization decisions, funded statuses for pensions, changes in allowances/provisions for payments, etc. This quarter, top line estimates again proved challenging for low attribute names, suggesting that either the bar for expectations was either too high or low attribute names witnessed notable misses that sustained technical deterioration.

Technical Upgrades and Downgrades
Earnings season still brings surprises, often in the form of big share price reactions. After a large share price reaction, our technical attribute ratings can adjust — we call these changes in rating technical upgrades and technical downgrades. By our definition, a technical upgrade is when a stock gains an attribute — so a 1-rated stock moving up to a 2 would classify, just as a 4-attribute stock moving up to a 5 would classify. A technical downgrade is the opposite, so it counts whenever a stock loses an attribute rating.
It is important to recognize that just because a stock received a technical upgrade, it is not instantly a high attribute stock worth buying. Recall that a stock that was a 0 and became a 1 is classified as a technical upgrade. Also, note that the chart below does not show maintained ratings. So, a 5-attribute stock that had a positive earnings surprise is nowhere to be seen, just like a 0-attribute stock that may have experienced further downside. Nonetheless, interesting trends emerged. Data pulled is from 9/10/2026 – 11/18/2026.
Sector Highlights:
- Q3 saw seven of the eleven sectors see more technical upgrades than downgrades with industrials, materials, and consumer staples being the sectors with the highest percentages. The largest swing in technical upgrades belongs to consumer staples with 16% of stocks seeing upgrades in Q3, after seeing zero stocks having technical upgrades in Q2 2026. Materials also witnessed a large change quarter over quarter with 17% seeing upgrades in Q3 after just 4% saw upgrades in Q2.
- Notable sectors to see decreases in technical upgrades from Q2 to Q3 were healthcare and consumer discretionary. After seeing 24% of the sector with upgrades in Q2, healthcare fell to 14% in Q3, while discretionary fell from 16% in Q2 to 8% in Q3.
- Four sectors saw more technical downgrades than upgrades with technology and energy witnessing the largest percentage of downgrades in Q3. Technology has been among the sectors with the largest percentage downgrades for the past two quarters.
- The most improved stocks from sectors that saw the most notable technical upgrades following earnings were DuPont (DD), Altria Group (MO), and Packaging Corp. of America (PKG). Other notables to see improvement this quarter post earnings were Airbnb (ABNB), GoDaddy Inc. (GDDY), IDEXX Laboratories (IDXX), and AppLovin (APP).
- The stocks within the S&P 500 Index that witnessed the most notable technical downgrades following earnings were the F5 Inc. (FFIV), Morgan Stanley (MS), Servicenow (NOW), and Palantir (PLTR).
