How combining indicators can produce a better experience for risk-off readings.
Shifting your portfolio to defense can seem like an art instead of a science when done without a process. Everyone wants to have a strategy that correctly times the market, shifting allocation to the sidelines to avoid major declines then jumping back into the market to ride the next ascent. We have a variety of defensive triggers available on the NDW platform that seek do just that. Last Friday, we reviewed six different hypothetical portfolios that used variations of three domestic equity indicators including the Bogey Check, Money Market Percentile Rank (MMPR) and Cash Percentile Rank. As the article discussed, each of the strategies “worked” in the sense that they showed better risk-adjusted returns than simply buying and holding the S&P 500 Index during our testing timeframe (9/30/2005 – 11/9/2026). None of them worked every time, but they all delivered a better investing experience when accounting for both returns and risk. We hope that understanding the differences in the indicators can help you choose which strategy best fits the needs of your clients.
One of the most popular strategies from those examined follows the MMPR70 trigger. We also use this approach in many of the Fund Score Method (FSM) models seen on our platform. This approach looks at the MMPR at the end of each month and shifts the entire portfolio to cash if that reading is above 70%. In other words, if our cash proxy is ranking better than 70% of the asset classifications on the Asset Class Group Scores page, the strategy moves to the sidelines. The indicator will continue to be defensive until the MMPR falls back below 70% at the end of a subsequent month. The graphic below shows the MMPR70 triggers in a backtest from 9/30/2005 through 11/16/2026. Note that our study last week looked at hypothetical intramonth triggers, while the version used in our models only examines the MMPR reading at the end of each month.

The MMPR70 trigger has seen six defensive moves since the inception of our backtest on 9/30/2005. Following those triggers has worked over time, but the indicator has not been perfect every time. Some of the defensive moves turned out to be headfakes, which are an unfortunate reality of any trend-following approach. These are those uncomfortable times when the indicator says to move to defense, only to have the market turn right back around and rip higher while your portfolio is on the sidelines. The MMPR reading is designed to move quickly, so, it will typically not stay wrong for long. If a headfake occurs, the system adjusts, with the MMPR moving lower to get the portfolio back in-line with the market action. Still, it would be great to be able to weed out instances where the market could be prone to a false signal.
Combining a trend following indicator with participation readings could help achieve that goal. Near-term participation readings can help provide perspective on market action and are most helpful at identifying potential bottoms. One of the most popular is the Ten Week for SPX (^TWSPX), which measures the percentage of stocks in the S&P 500 Index that are trading above their 10-week (50 day) moving averages. When this reading gets low, it highlights a lack of breadth. Most stocks are moving in the same direction, and that direction is down. Therefore, if we get a bounce higher, those same stocks would be prone to more correlated improvement.
We have seen that false signals often occur after a market wash-out event. For example, let’s say the market has been showing turbulent action, causing some concerning movement from readings like the MMPR. We get close to a 10% correction for the broader market. This is not enough weakness to cause the MMPR to spike above 70%, but perhaps it does get to 40% or 50%. Then we get a wash-out event where the market dips sharply over a few days, causing the MMPR reading to spike above 70%. Meanwhile, we can see the wash-out event through near-term participation readings like the TWSPX falling to low levels, typically identified by readings below 30%. So, we have the MMPR indicating a move to defense, but we would not want to take that trigger when the TWSPX is in low field position. This allows us to remain invested in the market to ride the potential appreciation that can come after low breadth readings. The graphic below shows the same MMPR70 triggers shown before, but with the TWSPX overlay highlighting low participation instances.

To implement the participation readings, we used the following rules that are included in the test shown below:
- Follow the MMPR70 indicator, moving the portfolio to defense when it triggers and the TWSPX is above 30%.
- If the MMPR70 triggers but the TWSPX is below 30%, remain invested.
- If the MMPR70 remains triggered, follow a trailing stop strategy with a rise and subsequent 20% drop for the TWSPX to indicate a move to defense. For example, if the TWSPX rises to 70% then falls to 50%, move to defense.
- When the MMPR falls below 70%, move back to fully invested and revert to rule 1.

Incorporating the TWSPX readings with the MMPR70 indicator does not make the strategy perfect. However, it does improve the investment experience by eliminating some of the false signals that can add drag on the portfolio over time. Combining these indicators proved to be beneficial as they provide different perspectives on market action. Said another way, they are not looking at the same thing or simply adding layers of momentum on top of one another. There are other combinations of indicators that could be beneficial but remember to diversify your perspective when determining what approach is best for you. Regardless of what indicators you decide to use, it is most important to define your process ahead of time and stick to that process amid uncertainty.