Misconceptions of Valuations
Published: November 16, 2026
This content is for informational purposes only. This should not be construed as solicitation. The general public should consult their financial advisor for additional information related to investment decisions.
Given the anxiety of valuation levels, we look at where things stand, as well as the new PnF chart of the S&P 500's P/E ratio.

Market regime shifts are an inevitable part of investing, and one of the biggest factors in those shifts is market valuations. Bull markets are often accompanied by loftier valuations, while bear markets are often started once those valuations come back to earth.

If investors keep up to date with markets, then they’ve heard a lot about the price to earnings (P/E) ratio recently. But for all the talk about the metric, there can be a lot of misconceptions behind it. Given the sharp movement in the market over the last few months, especially within technology, it might be time to revisit it… while giving some technical perspective too.

Do Valuations Look… Normal?

Indices can rise through increases in valuations, earnings, or both. But if valuations are falling, it can be a headwind for index returns, as earnings need to grow by a wider margin for the same level of return. The average forward P/E of the S&P 500 (SPX) since 1990 is around 16. The last few years have seen it as high as 22.5, drawing parallels to the euphoria of the dot com bubble.

But given how strong earnings continue to look, the growth areas of the market are sitting in much more reasonable territory than previous highs. The forward P/E for SPX has fallen down below 18, which is below its average over the last ten years and outside of the top 25% of readings since 1990. Furthermore, market valuations are no longer being elevated by the technology sector. The Technology Select Sector SPDR ETF (XLK)’s forward P/E was recently below 17, a full point lower than the S&P 500. The last time tech was a full point cheaper in P/E than the market was early 2016, so the sector is the cheapest it has been relative to the market in over a decade!

For context, the forward P/E of technology was 1.9 times that of the S&P 500 at the end of March 2000. Meanwhile, the Nasdaq-100 (NDX) traded at a forward P/E multiple of 89.2 at the peak of the dotcom bubble. Today, that number stands at a more reasonable 19.5, meaning NDX would need to rise 357% overnight to reach those euphoric valuations, making today’s market much less comparable to the tech bubble. That said, such cheap relative valuations could signal a lack of confidence in the sustainability of tech earnings if the AI buildout slows.

Additionally, longer-term measures of value sill remain elevated compared to historical averages. One sign of danger for the market is the Shiller cyclically adjusted price-to-earnings ratio (CAPE), which looks at the price of the S&P 500 (SPX) relative to its inflation adjusted earnings over the last ten years. The metric has made headlines lately with it nearing all-time euphoric levels near 40, which had previously only been matched prior to the dotcom crash, with the 2022 bear market close at 35.

Historically, the CAPE has a coefficient of determination of 0.49 with the S&P 500’s return over the next 10 years, meaning that it explains around half of market returns over the next decade. While that might not hold up going forward, that’s an extremely strong correlation for something as noisy as markets.

Valuations Aren’t a Timing Tool

However, most advisors and portfolio managers don’t operate on decade-long time-horizons. The next several months are often what matters most when tactically allocating portfolios.

Lofty valuations can always become loftier in the near-term, while a cheap market can always become cheaper. As a result, the P/E has almost no correlation with market returns over the next several months across most environments.

Whether it’s the normal P/E or the CAPE, both explain less than 1% of the variance in the market over the next three months, and around 2% over the next six months. All that to say, valuations can fall short when investors need to make tactical allocation decisions for today’s market.

Every Market Is Unique

The lost decade, including the dot com bubble and the GFC, stands out as the most notable instance of elevated CAPE valuations above 25. But even with those examples, there was no valuation level dictating that investors should sell immediately. Leading up to the great recession, CAPE peaked at 27.55 in May 2007 and bottomed out at 13.3 in March 2009. But in the case of the dotcom bubble, markets reached a CAPE above 25 at the end of 1995, with the S&P 500 rising another 155% before peaking at 44.2 at the end of 1999.

Most recently, the S&P 500 reached CAPE levels above 25 in June of 2014 only seen before the dotcom bubble and the great recession. In the following year, Robert Shiller—the creator of the ratio—said, “the CAPE ratio serves as a warning signal... I think this is a risky time,” adding he reduced exposure to US stocks. The CAPE ratio has stayed above 24 the entire time since then while the S&P 500 gained ~380% on a total return basis, demonstrating strong long-term returns are possible even at high valuations.

There’s only been so many market environments, and each new one presents investors with unique considerations, meaning we should take any “foolproof” indicators with a grain of salt. The inversion of the yield curve forecasted every recession since 1970... until it predicted a recession that never manifested in 2022. There is decent a chance a bear market occurs in the next few years, but that possibility is present in all market environments, not just this one. Even though valuations are historically a solid determinant of outlook in the long run, it can often take significant lengths of time to achieve that long-term state. And as economist John Maynard Keynes put it, “in the long run we’re all dead.”

Follow the Trend, Not the Level

Because of Keynes and other economists, the Federal Reserve no longer operates by passively waiting for the market to achieve long-term equilibrium. Instead, the institution evaluates the current trend of indicators and makes policy decisions that impact the present situation. Similarly, given the extended time it can take for valuations to normalize, the movement or trend of the P/E ratio can often be a better gauge of valuation’s impact than the level itself, especially over shorter horizons.

NDW is happy to unveil daily S&P 500 P/E ratios in Point and Figure form, allowing investors to more easily identify whether valuations are expanding or contracting. The trailing S&P 500 P/E ratio (SPXLTMPE) goes back as far as 1954, while the forward P/E ratio (SPXNTMPE) goes back to 1990. And looking at the PnF chart of the trailing P/E ratio, it’s apparent that valuations tend to trend in one direction or the other.

Valuations have moved consistently higher during this bull market, apart from dips during the tariff tantrum and the last few months. Due to a combination of earnings growth and market consolidation, it has pulled back slightly and moved to a sell signal in August. But for now, the P/E ratio remains in the positive trend it began in 2023.

Whether valuations move into a full-blown downtrend will be key market factor in 2027, as there will be a higher bar for earnings growth to keep the same level of returns. So far, markets have delivered on growth, with earnings rising by more than 20% over the last year, but whether it continues to do so is the multi trillion-dollar question. In meantime, chartists can follow the valuation indicator for signs of further change.

Back to report

DISCLOSURE

This report is for Internal Use Only and not for distribution to the public. While we make every effort to be free of errors in this report, it contains data obtained from other sources. We believe these sources to be reliable, but we cannot guarantee their accuracy. Investors who use options should read the Options Disclosure Document before making any particular investment decision. Officers or employees of this firm may now or in the future have a position in the stocks mentioned in this report. Dorsey, Wright is a Registered Investment Advisor with the U.S. Securities & Exchange Commission. Copies of Form ADV Part II are available upon request.
Equity prices provided by Thomson-Reuters. Cross Rate prices provided by Tenfore Systems. Option prices provided by OPRA
Copyright © 1995-2026 Dorsey, Wright & Associates, LLC.®
All quotes displayed are delayed 20 minutes
Disclaimer/Terms of Use/Copyright